How much do general social anxieties around demographics and sexuality interact with each other? I've seen a number of historians connect early 19th century concerns about falling birthrates with increasingly controlling attitudes towards non-procreative sex. But is there cause and effect? We could look around today's America and ask "is the nativist anxiety about white birthrates tied in any way to surges of hostility against marginalized genders and sexualities? To be sure, I've occasionally seen anti-trans comments to the effect of "they're destroying their reproductive protential." And it definitely feels like there's a connection between anxieties around white birthrates and anti-abortion forces. But the current picture is far more complex than that. The dynamics were likely to have been similarly complex in the 19th century. The cyclical recurrence of "sex/gender panics" and the ways in which they manifest would be worth studying as a topic on its own, just as the cyclicity of feminist progress and repression is worth studying. Once you see it, the whole illusion of unidirctional social progress evaporates. We may start each cycle from a different status quo, but we never seem to solve the underlying issues and anxieties that generate the next cycle.
Comments